Salesforce, a global leader in cloud-based customer relationship management (CRM) solutions, has consistently set benchmarks for innovation in the enterprise software sector. Its journey, marked by continuous technological advancements in areas like artificial intelligence, data analytics, and collaborative platforms, underscores the critical role intellectual property (IP) plays in maintaining market leadership. A deep dive into Salesforce’s patent portfolio reveals not just a robust defense mechanism but also a proactive strategy to shape the future of cloud software, reflecting a sophisticated approach to IP management that mirrors its business acumen.
Evolving Litigation Landscape and Strategic IP Defense
The dynamic nature of the cloud software industry inevitably brings evolving litigation challenges. Salesforce has navigated this landscape with a strategic and focused approach to IP defense. While the company has faced a range of patent disputes, a notable trend indicates that Non-Practicing Entities (NPEs) have historically constituted a significant portion of the litigation landscape targeting Salesforce. This highlights the industry-wide challenge of managing asserted patents from entities whose primary business model revolves around licensing or litigating intellectual property.
Salesforce’s proactive stance is evident in its engagement with Inter Partes Reviews (IPRs). In recent years, the company has strategically utilized IPRs to challenge the validity of patents asserted against it. For instance, in a few instances during the 2021-2024 period, Salesforce initiated IPRs, particularly against patents held by operating companies, signaling a focused defense tactic when faced with potential litigation. This approach underscores a commitment to thoroughly evaluating and, where appropriate, challenging the foundational strength of patents brought against its innovations.
Litigation Trends: Focused Defense in Key Jurisdictions
Beyond NPEs, Salesforce’s litigation footprint reveals a concentrated effort in specific judicial venues known for their experience in patent matters. A significant portion of its patent cases, totaling over 70 disputes, have been concentrated in the Eastern District of Texas (EDTX) and the Western District of Texas (WDTX). Collectively, these two districts account for more than 40% of Salesforce’s total patent cases. This strategic engagement in these forums, often favored for their efficient case management and established patent litigation procedures, demonstrates Salesforce’s deliberate approach to defending its intellectual property rights and innovations.
Influencing Innovation: Salesforce’s Patents as Industry Benchmarks
Salesforce’s robust patent portfolio not only serves as a strong defensive shield but also acts as a powerful lever to influence the broader technological landscape. The strength of its innovations is evident in how often its patents are leveraged by patent examiners to reject applications from other companies. This “prior art” impact underscores Salesforce’s foundational contributions to cloud software and related technologies.
Here are some of Salesforce’s highly influential patents, based on their use as prior art in rejecting competitor applications:
| Patent Number | Number of Applications Rejected | Key Companies Impacted |
|---|---|---|
| US8788492B2 | More than 50 | Google LLC, Meta Platforms Inc., Microsoft Technology Licensing, IBM, Yahoo! Inc., Airbnb Inc. |
| US10701054B2 | Approximately 27 | (Companies not specified, but widely cited) |
| US9984126B2 | Approximately 25 | (Companies not specified, but widely cited) |
| US9240016B2 | Approximately 22 | (Companies not specified, but widely cited) |
| US9479387B2 | Approximately 22 | (Companies not specified, but widely cited) |
Note: The patent set considered for the insight is till September 2024.
Competitive Landscape: Paving the Way in Cloud Software
The significant influence of Salesforce’s patent portfolio is further highlighted by its impact on other leading technology companies. Examiners have frequently cited Salesforce’s patents to issue rejections for applications filed by competitors, indicating that these companies are developing technologies in similar domains. This often suggests potential avenues for future collaboration or licensing, as these firms are operating within Salesforce’s established technological footprint.
Here are some of the top companies whose patent applications faced rejections or were eventually abandoned due to Salesforce’s existing patents, showcasing the strength and breadth of Salesforce’s IP:
| Company Name | Number of Rejections (Insight 2) | Number of Abandoned Patents (Insight 3) |
|---|---|---|
| IBM (International Business Machines) | Over 290 | Approximately 56 |
| Microsoft (Microsoft Technology Licensing) | Over 270 | Approximately 56 |
| SAP SE | Nearly 100 | Approximately 20 |
| Oracle | Nearly 90 | (Not specified for abandonment) |
| Meta (Meta Platforms Inc.) | Over 60 | Approximately 13 |
| Google LLC | (Not specified for rejections) | Approximately 10 |
These figures underscore Salesforce’s leading position, as its innovations frequently form the baseline for patentability in the cloud and enterprise software sectors.
Forward Citation Data: Salesforce’s Influence in Critical Technical Domains
The foundational nature of Salesforce’s innovations is also reflected in the high number of forward citations its patents receive. These citations indicate that subsequent patents from other entities are building upon, or are related to, Salesforce’s prior work. This not only validates the originality and significance of Salesforce’s contributions but also identifies areas of high impact and potential for future collaboration or licensing.
Below are five of Salesforce’s most cited patents over the last decade, highlighting their extensive influence across the industry:
| Patent Number | Total Citations | Core Technologies |
|---|---|---|
| US9760620B2 | Over 280 | Data Clustering, Machine Learning Applications |
| US9619652B2 | Over 210 | Risk Scoring, Data Privacy Compliance |
| US10430608B2 | Over 200 | Automated Compliance, Risk Assessment Technologies |
| US10282663B2 | Over 110 | (Areas related to the above, widely foundational) |
| US10346721B2 | Over 100 | (Areas related to the above, widely foundational) |
This data is for patents published in the last 10 years.
These patents exemplify Salesforce’s role in advancing critical areas, signaling opportunities for engagement with companies whose innovations align with these foundational technologies.
Salesforce’s Multiple IP Strategies: Optimizing Portfolio Growth
Salesforce employs a multifaceted approach to IP strategy, ensuring its innovations are protected efficiently and effectively. Two notable tactical moves within its patent filing processes are the strategic use of Track One requests and Non-Publication Requests (NPRs). These distinct strategies offer competitive advantages in different scenarios, reflecting a sophisticated understanding of patent prosecution.
Track One Requests: Accelerating Key Innovations
In the past three years, Salesforce successfully obtained grants for over 1,490 U.S. patents. Among these, approximately 35 patents were expedited through the Track One program, also known as Prioritized Examination. This allows for a significantly faster review process, enabling companies to secure critical patent protection more quickly and accelerate market entry for their innovations. While this option involves a higher fee, Salesforce strategically applies it to technologies deemed critical for immediate market impact or competitive advantage.
Salesforce has prioritized Track One requests for patents related to:
- Collaboration & Communication Platforms: Including cross-organization collaboration and communication integration.
- Database & System Performance: Focusing on multi-tenant database management and overall system efficiency.
- Security & Permission Management: Innovations in external communication security and access control.
This targeted use of Track One indicates Salesforce’s commitment to bringing cutting-edge solutions to market swiftly in these high-priority areas.
Non-Publication Requests: Maintaining Confidentiality and Market Advantage
Another strategic tool Salesforce utilizes is the Non-Publication Request (NPR), filed for approximately 53 U.S. patents out of more than 2,500 granted in the last five years. An NPR allows a company to delay the public disclosure of a patent application, maintaining confidentiality around an innovation until it is ready for commercialization or international filing. This approach provides a significant advantage, enabling Salesforce to protect its product’s market share by delaying competitors’ access to its latest technological advancements.
The technologies identified under Salesforce’s NPR strategy include:
- Natural Language Generation (NLG): Focused on AI-driven systems for generating narratives from data.
- Group Communication and Collaboration: Enhancements in chat platforms, smart event scheduling, and personalized communication features.
- AI-based Language Understanding: Innovations in how AI processes and interprets human language.
- Resource Optimization and Event Scheduling: Technologies for managing time and resources, often derived from communication analysis.
The use of NPRs in these sensitive areas suggests that Salesforce views these innovations as particularly vital to its business, seeking to protect them from early exposure and potential replication.
Geographic Patent Filing Trends: Salesforce’s Global Innovation Footprint
Salesforce’s patent filing strategy clearly delineates its global market priorities, with a heavy emphasis on key established markets while maintaining a growing presence in select emerging regions.
| Jurisdiction | Number of Filings | Insights on Strategic Focus |
|---|---|---|
| United States (US) | Over 9,000 | Primary market, strong foothold in cloud/SaaS, aligns with company origin. |
| European Patents (EP) | Approximately 270 | Efforts to protect IP across a broader international landscape. |
| WO-WIPO Filings | Approximately 250 | Strategic approach to streamline global IP protection. |
| China (CN) | Over 100 | Targeted efforts in a key Asia-Pacific market. |
| Japan (JP) | Over 40 | Growing importance for Salesforce’s business in Asia. |
| Canada (CA) | Approximately 80 | Selective IP protection outside primary markets. |
| Australia (AU) | Over 60 | Selective IP protection outside primary markets. |
| Germany (DE) | A few | Limited but strategic focus in specific European markets. |
| Taiwan (TW) | A few | Very targeted presence, potential for future growth. |
| Hong Kong (HK) | One | Very limited immediate focus. |
Source: Lens.org data
Salesforce’s patent distribution indicates a focus on protecting its innovations in established markets. While the U.S. remains its cornerstone, its moderate presence in Europe and targeted growth in Asia-Pacific markets like China and Japan highlight a calculated approach to global IP protection.
Furthermore, Salesforce has strategically increased its international patent activity. Its WIPO application filings, for instance, saw a modest increase from a few in 2011–2015 to a small number in 2016–2020. Similarly, European Patent (EP) filings grew notably, reflecting a strengthened focus on securing intellectual property protection in key European markets. In Asia, particularly China, filings surged significantly, from a single application in 2011–2015 to over 30 in 2016–2020. Japan also emerged as a key area with numerous filings in the latter period, alongside increases in Hong Kong and India. This strategic growth in Asia-Pacific reflects Salesforce’s expanding presence in these vital technology markets.
Strategic Legal Partnerships: Supporting Salesforce’s IP Journey
The successful management of a vast and influential patent portfolio like Salesforce’s relies heavily on strategic legal partnerships. Salesforce collaborates with a network of top-tier law firms and attorneys who provide expertise in navigating the complexities of patent prosecution across various jurisdictions.
Over the past decade (2014-2024), several law firms have been instrumental in supporting Salesforce’s patent activities:
| Law Firm | Number of Patents Filed (Overall) |
|---|---|
| Holland & Hart LLP | Approximately 130 |
| Lee & Hayes, P.C. | Over 100 |
| Sterne, Kessler, Goldstein & Fox P.L.L.C. | Nearly 100 |
| Butzel Long | Approximately 90 |
| Kowert, Hood, Munyon, Rankin & Goetzel, P.C. | Over 70 |
This data is based on Salesforce as the original assignee.
When examining top jurisdictions for the most recent five-year period (2019-2024), Holland & Hart LLP continues its strong support for Salesforce in the U.S. with over 120 filings, while Bryn-Jacobsen, Caelia, stands out for managing a significant number of European filings, with nearly 50 patents. These partnerships highlight Salesforce’s commitment to leveraging specialized legal expertise for its global IP protection.
Global Talent Pool: Fueling Salesforce’s Innovation
While Salesforce is headquartered in the United States, its innovation engine is fueled by a diverse global talent pool. An analysis of inventor countries over the past decade (2013-2023) reveals that while the majority of its innovation originates from inventors in the U.S., Salesforce strategically leverages expertise from other key countries, including Canada, India, Singapore, and Argentina. This global distribution of inventor talent underscores Salesforce’s commitment to harnessing diverse perspectives and skills to drive its technological progress and maintain its leadership in the cloud software industry.
Conclusion: A Masterclass in IP-Driven Growth
Salesforce’s intellectual property strategy is a comprehensive testament to its leadership in the cloud software industry. From its proactive defense against litigation and its significant influence on the competitive landscape through foundational patents, to its strategic use of accelerated examination and non-publication requests, Salesforce demonstrates a sophisticated approach to managing its innovations. The company’s global patent footprint, particularly its strong presence in the U.S. and growing focus in Asia, combined with its reliance on a global inventor talent pool and expert legal partnerships, positions it as a master of IP-driven growth. As the cloud and AI landscape continues to evolve, Salesforce’s dynamic and strategic IP management will undoubtedly remain a key differentiator, safeguarding its innovations and shaping the future of enterprise technology.
Subscribe to our newsletter for insights into patent filings, litigation shifts, licensing opportunities, and strategy breakdowns across tech and innovation-driven sectors.
Get the Latest Patent Insights in Cloud Services
Directly to Your Inbox
English